“Our intention was to confront the Lubavitcher Rebbe and challenge him that we thought he was trying to displace G-d.”
[A letter sent in the mid 80’s to the editor of The Jewish Press, New York]
Dear Editor,
I read with pleasure your article on Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn. I had the great fortune to personally experience this remarkable rabbi’s dedication to helping Jews return to the observance of mitzvot. Even today, many decades later and despite the anemia of old age, I blush when I recall the chutzpa displayed by six of my friends and I towards Rabbi Schneersohn, and how we were gently turned around.
It was in 1929, when several articles appeared in various Jewish newspapers available in Philadelphia in those days about one Rabbi Schneersohn, the [sixth] Lubavitcher Rebbe. These articles quoted the Rebbe at great length and in much detail [concerning his thoughts and plans about Torah observant Judaism in America –yt]. My friends and I read these articles and wondered amongst ourselves whether the Rebbe was actually planning to replace the Al-mighty. We discussed this with an official of our synagogue, and he suggested that we visit the Rebbe and ask him what he had in mind.
He was referring to the fact that one of the articles had mentioned that the Rebbe had been given the use of a house on 33rd Street by Mrs. Faggen-Miller, a woman well known for her charitable nature. Accordingly, late that Saturday evening we all piled into the car [yes, in those days even the smallest American cars sat 3 in the front and 4 in the back. –y.t.] and drove to the listed address. Our intention was to confront the Rebbe and challenge him that we thought he was trying to displace G-d.
As we climbed the steps to the front porch, we saw through the window that the living room was crowded with men. We rang the doorbell and a dignified, bearded man came to the door and inquired what we wanted.
One of us responded: “We’d like to speak to the Rebbe. We have an important question to ask.”
All this time the man was taking notes. We subsequently found out that he was Rabbi Yehezkel Feigen, the Rebbe’s personal secretary.
“About what?” he said: “The Rebbe must know the question before he can see you.”
“Well,” (we knew we couldn’t tell this man our originally intended question, so we answered), “we’d like to know how he expects us to keep an old-fashioned religion in a modern country.”
“You’ll have to wait,” he said. “You see how there is quite a crowd before you. But come in.”
We told him we’d wait on the porch as there wouldn’t be room for all of us in the packed living room. In a few minutes he returned and said that the Rebbe would see us at once. He ushered us into the house, through the crowded living room, and up the stairs. We wondered why we had been admitted before all those people downstairs who had been there before us.
At the top of the stairs stood the Rabbi. He was tall, handsome, and saintly looking, with gleaming, bright eyes. He wore a large fur hat. His hand was outstretched in greeting. I was surprised since I never knew that Chassidic rebbes extended their hands in greeting.
“This is the happiest moment I’ve had in Philadelphia,” he said as he started to arrange chairs around his desk. We tried to help him, but he insisted that he wanted to do this task himself.
Once we were seated he took a long look at each one of us and then began: “You look like very intelligent young men, and therefore I must speak on your level. You are wondering about those people downstairs who were here before you. Well, here are some of the problems for which they are asking help.
“One man’s daughter is seriously ill. What can I do? Nothing more than he can do, provided he approaches G-d sincerely. He should be able to ask for a complete recovery.
“Another has a lawsuit and wants me to pray that he will win. I do not know who’s right, but he can pray that the L-rd will give justice.
“There is a man who wants to buy a business and wants me to intercede to make sure it succeeds. If I could do that, I’d be a rich business man.
“But if I could not answer your question, I’d have no right to be a rabbi.”
The Rebbe smiled and continued. “First, I must admit a great secret, which I trust you will most likely keep. There are 613 mitzvot, and while the Lubavitcher Rebbe tries to keep them all, he finds it impossible to keep them all. So what does he do? Discard all 613 mitzvot? No, he keeps as many of them as humanly possible.”
With these few words he removed the venom we had brought with us.
Then he asked us to try and keep as many mitzvot as we could. If we kept as many as we could, then we’d be doing the same thing as the Lubavitcher Rebbe!
Then he asked for our Jewish names and the names of our mothers. We also offered our legal names and addresses but he said he had no use for them. Several of the boys put their hands in their pockets, but he stopped them with a gesture, thanked us, and said he had no use for our money; what he wanted from us was mitzvot.
He asked us whether we put on tefillin every day. Several admitted they had given up. Whereupon he offered them tefillin so they could fulfill the mitzva. All of us promised to try to live up to his suggestions. He then blessed us individually and shook hands with us again, and we left.
We stood on the porch for nearly two hours digesting the visit.
Everyone agreed to pray at least once a day. One said he would give up his Saturday work as a dental technician and some months later he even prevailed upon his employer to do the same.
One of us, Gabriel Lowenthal, of blessed memory, attached himself to a synagogue and taught what he had learned from the Rebbe’s philosophy to many others. I have lost track of some of the boys, but I’m sure that the ten minutes we spent with the Rebbe strengthened the spirit of Judaism for all of us.
The depression and later World War II gave me little hope of ever gaining more light from Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak. However, I found continued inspiration from his son-in-law, the present Rebbe, to keep as many of the 613 mitzvot as I can.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
[Source: Adapted by Yerachmiel Tilles from “Chassidic Gems vol. I”, by Tuvia Litzman]
Rabbi Yerachmiel Tilles is co-founder of Ascent, webmaster and managing editor of KabbalaOnline.org and ascentofsafed.com. He has hundreds of published stories to his credit.
The books of Rabbi Yerachmiel Tilles can be purchased at https://www.kabbalaonline-shop.com/searchresults.asp?Search=Tilles&Submit=
PLEASE DO NOT PUBLISH THIS STORY IN PRINT OR ELECTRONIC FORM WITHOUT EXPLICIT PERMISSION FROM Rabbi Yerachmiel Tilles (editor@ascentofsafed.com)
The Ascent storyteller WhatsApp group:
A different Audio, Video and Print story each Saturday night!
To Join “TillesTells”, go to:
https://chat.whatsapp.com/Ez7giF6pXdRBeqG0vZfWkL
or send a WhatsApp request to +972-526-770-137
(for an email subscription for the print story, go to